Rihanna Redefines her Image

Just two years ago, the Barbadian vocalist Rihanna was playfully shimmying her way through the fluorescent-and-neon video for “Pon De Replay,” an innocuous dancehall confection about as threatening as cotton candy. It was the perfect pop lark, the kind of song that’s designed for pre-teen sleepovers and rowdy ice cream socials.
So it was a bit of a shock when Rihanna strode onstage to that song at the Nokia Theatre Times Square decked out in thigh-high lace-up boots, a black, strappy bustier, and a black leather tutu with silver studs that highlighted her finer points. This was our one-time 17-year-old sweetheart? You think you know a person.
Actually, resisting definition has been something of a guiding principle for Rihanna. Where other pop stars aim early to establish a persona - invented or otherwise - Rihanna has succeeded by remaining something of a cipher, able to apply her modest voice to a number of different milieus. She’s tinkered a bit with reggae, R&B and icy electropop without staking hard claim to any of them. This past summer, she achieved pop ubiquity with a song that was popular not so much for its chorus as for a couple of syllables - specifically, the syllables that make up the back half of its title, “Umbrella.”
That song is from her latest record, “Good Girl Gone Bad,” a phrase that explains the Bondage Goes Broadway motif. It took a long time for Rihanna to finally get to that album’s best songs, but when she did the results were scarily effective. “Shut Up and Drive,” a song that purloins the riff from New Order’s “Blue Monday,” hurtled forward on its own momentum, spurred on by growling guitars. “Breakin’ Dishes” was halting and harrowing, Rihanna slicing the word “man” into a million little pieces and spitting out each as she tiptoed across the lip of the stage. And for “Sell Me Candy,” she batted around a long leather flogger while her dancers thrust angrily against each other.
In the end, though, all of this dressing up was just costumes and props. Rihanna was no more believable as a done-up dominatrix than she was as a teenage dancehall star. And though poise and professionalism weren’t in short supply, Rihanna proved distressingly devoid of any kind of conviction. There was a sense of detachment throughout the performance that was difficult to shake. There was nothing about the material that was specific to Rihanna, and nothing to suggest the songs - and perhaps the outfits, too - couldn’t be handled just as ably by anyone else.
When the time finally came for “Umbrella,” the grim weather seemed like canny planning. A few measures into the song’s swooping introduction and the audience was gamely hoisting the titular accessory into the air. Though that maneuver probably sent the superstitious in the crowd screaming for the doors, it underscored the song’s expressions of solidarity.
Besides, why fear invisible boogeymen when you’ve got threatening stilettos and a fierce black whip?
Related Stories
POSTED IN: Rihanna News

7 opinions for Rihanna Redefines her Image
rebecca
Mar 9, 2008 at 10:49 am
i love rihanna
is the best singer
i give you my luu
annika
Apr 1, 2008 at 7:48 am
i love rihanna
she is the best singer in the world!!!!
hvis jeg møder hende engang hved jeg ikke helt hvordan jeg skal raregere!!?? :d
anita
Apr 9, 2008 at 10:13 am
i love RiHaNnA.ShE iS ThE bEsT sInGeR i LoVe YoU RiHaNnA
kirsty
Apr 13, 2008 at 4:37 am
hi x
i was going to c your concert but u had a sor throt u rock u r the bast
kirsty x
albulena
Apr 13, 2008 at 3:46 pm
helo rihana i love you tu muq
sema
Apr 18, 2008 at 3:19 am
rihanna is the besttt i love youuuu 4-ever you are sweet and beutiful
Farai liwewe
Apr 28, 2008 at 1:04 pm
Hey
Rihanna.u a great singer.i love ur hair.kip intouch.xoxo
Have an opinion? Leave a comment: